Originally Posted By TXDISNEYNERD Singing dalmatians would probably do better than Tim will. Bless his heart.
Originally Posted By TXDISNEYNERD Yup, Tim did not impress, but he is a cutie pie so he might stay a while. Lee was my favorite last night, followed by Crystal and Casey.
Originally Posted By trekkeruss But at least Tim was in tune. Siohban on the other hand, was the worst of the night singing-wise (but I doubt she'll be bottom three.)
Originally Posted By Dabob2 Yeah, Lee really came through and vaulted himself into the top tier (at least for a week - probably longer since his primary problem was self-confidence, and this must have given him a healthy boost of that), and Andrew vaulted himself into "should at least stick around a few more weeks" territory, unless too many voters had already written him off. Crystal has yet to disappoint. She was my second favorite of the night, and still easily my favorite of the season. My bottom tier of forgettables continues to be that - my guess is the tween girls will continue to vote for Tim and Aaron, so Didi or Katie goes home tonight. Siobhan would be vulnerable if she hadn't been so good on previous shows - she had an off night but probably has enough fans from previous weeks to vote her through.
Originally Posted By trekkeruss Top tier was Lee, Crystal, Andrew, and Casey. In the middle are Mike, Katie, and Aaron. Siobhan was bad, but she should be safe because of past performances and fans. Didi and Tim will be in danger, and probably Katie too. I think bottom two will be Katie and Didi; hard to say who will go. Personally I think it should be Didi.
Originally Posted By amazedncal2 I thought Tim should go. I would have liked the bottom 2 to be Tim and Aaron. I'm sorry that Didi left because I liked her voice (yep, I said it again We zapped through most of Usher but from what I saw he was 100% less annoying than Miley and her minions.
Originally Posted By TXDISNEYNERD I was sorry DiDi left as I liked her voice too. I think Tim looked kinda shocked that it wasn't him.
Originally Posted By mele See, I don't think Tim is attractive at all. He looks terrified while he sings. Seriously, deer in the headlights. Also, he doesn't look intelligent at all with the scared look and the constant smiling cos he's "having fun".
Originally Posted By Jim in Merced CA Didi left. Hmmmm, they seem to be losing the people I really like. Tim? Andrew? Katie? Really???
Originally Posted By onlyme >>See, I don't think Tim is attractive at all. He looks terrified while he sings. Seriously, deer in the headlights. Also, he doesn't look intelligent at all with the scared look and the constant smiling cos he's "having fun".<< LOL! Yes, really does look like a deer in the headlights. Also, whenever a contestant gets some less-than-positive feedback, for god's sake, must they ALWAYS say that they were just up there having fun. Maybe it's true, but they all say it all the time. It's like some sort of defense mechanism. And, yes, I've said I was done watching, but my wife isn't, so I catch a bit here and there. And, for the love of god, Kara continues to make my skin crawl each time I look at her ridiculous face and the funky things she says. One more thing, can someone please ask Randy to stop saying, "Yo, Yo, Yo, that was Dope". I forgot his name, but one guy was awesome the other night. And, Mr. Smiley seems to be getting on Kara's nerves. She had the audacity to make the condescending remark that, "maybe he doesn't know what we're saying". What an egotistical lady.
Originally Posted By Jim in Merced CA <And, Mr. Smiley seems to be getting on Kara's nerves. She had the audacity to make the condescending remark that, "maybe he doesn't know what we're saying". What an egotistical lady.> my wife can't stand Kara. And yes, I thought her comment about Tim was really smug.
Originally Posted By amazedncal2 So far Kara hasn't bugged me that much. Maybe I'm not paying attention? I miss Paula's craziness. At least she had a music background and made sense with her critique. I continue to really enjoy Ellen anywhere other than on AI. She is offering nothing to the panel.
Originally Posted By Labuda Yeah, I'm really bummed about Ellen's job as a judge. And I'm really bummed that America is continuing to keep Andrew around. And kind of glad, though I don't vote for him, that my Texan boy is still in it for now (that's Tim).
Originally Posted By Jim in Merced CA I think Ellen is more 'the voice of the people' than anything else. I think she adds a nice softness to the going's on -- it can get a bit technical with Randy and Kara's comments. And of course, Simon is just Simon.
Originally Posted By Dabob2 I don't DISlike Ellen as a judge; she just seems kind of ... superfluous.
Originally Posted By LoyalOrderWaterBuffa when will these thieves stop stealing other artist works week after week a real artist creates and not steals like Van Halen. He made great new music. Have you heard of toni Basil she was a musical genious who created.
Originally Posted By Jim in Merced CA The contestants have to choose from set music that is approved by 'American Idol.'
Originally Posted By LoyalOrderWaterBuffa singers better stop ripping off other established artists. we are all sick of them bastardizing beautiful works of art and then getting famous for doing it. They are not fooling me
