Originally Posted By Labuda Aren't they required to do whatever song lost for them? I think that's always how they do it...
Originally Posted By gadzuux Yeah - they would have to do the song that the backup band is already primed for. I was thinking that they've been doing a particularly good job. The song choices are all over the map, and yet they always seem to manage to support the singer without overshadowing them. Nice job guys.
Originally Posted By Dlmusic It would be nice if that rule was changed and that people prepared a goodbye song. I know Latoya when she was kicked off sang a song from earlier in the season and not the song she sang when she was booted.
Originally Posted By chickendumpling Yes. Rule change please. I think it torture for them (and us) to have to do the losing song again.
Originally Posted By Labuda Ok, watching the show... 01 - Taylor - I enjoyd it, but what the heck is up with his movements while he sings? Just seems a bit silly. I do adore the guy, though! 02 - Ummm, Elliot I think was his name - pretty good, snoozer song 03 - Ace - *drool* but I hated the song 04 - Gedeon - did a great job of a Sam Cooke song - I like this kid, even though he's got a mouth the size of Mick Jagger's. 05 - Doogie Howser - teeny tiny lil' white boy sings Marvin Gaye. It was passable, but not great. Did better than I'd expect of a kid who looks like this 06 - Jose - don't like the song despite it being a Stevie Wonder one.... this is a first for me - but maybe that's jsut that I'm not a fan of this guy. 07 - Will - I'm with Paula - good tone, but I think he over controls it. And what does doing a Kenny Rogers song have to do with being a Texan? Does this kid think Kenny is a Texan? I SURE hope he's not confusing Kenny Rogers with Willie!
Originally Posted By Labuda 08 - Bucky - a bit rough in places, but I liked him. 09 - sinatra boy *YAWN* go on home and leave it to the big boys, son 10 - Chris Dautry - this guy rocked. GREAT job tonight! Loved the song, too. Oh, and Chicken Little boy could do a great job with songs in the style of Feargal Sharkey, I think.
Originally Posted By Labuda Yeah, it makes me think of a little chipmunk every tme I hear it. That, or Bucky the Beaver.
Originally Posted By chickendumpling Okay. Taylor just sang. Not my favorite song but I really like him and he should stay he has a nice voice. Can I just say that I am a TOTAL sucker for a guy with an accent? Not to mention one that can wink like that. His other twitches are kinda hard to get used to though. lol.
Originally Posted By chickendumpling Elliot. Sign me up! I am ready to buy his album now. He sure ain't no looker but man can that guy sing!
Originally Posted By Lisann22 Labuda???!!! Elliot is awesome. He is so smooth. Ok, only him and Taylor have sung so far. I loved his cool jazz. The boy can SING! I'll be back. ;>
Originally Posted By Rsey103 I liked Bucky, too. David disappointed. Elliot was great. Really enjoyed his performance. Hope he wins so he can get his teeth fixed.
Originally Posted By chickendumpling Ace disappointed. Too bad. I think he just had an off night though and I am willing to overlook tonight. Plus, I still want to run my fingers through his hair. lol.
Originally Posted By chickendumpling Gideon: Definite keeper. I have only ever seen pictures of WorldDisney but there is something about Gideon's smile that kinda reminds me of him. Did they just say that Chicken Little was gonna sing Marvin? This I gotta see.
Originally Posted By JazzCat I just about coughed up a lung when they put a picture of chicken little next to Kevin. Alright.........who from "American Idol" is reading LP?????????????????
Originally Posted By chickendumpling LOL! I thought the same thing. Did you see him wink - thinking he is the new Sex Idol. LOL. Apparently I am only a sucker for the wink if you are cute and over 21. Really likeable but really average performance I thought.
Originally Posted By JazzCat I cannot tell you in words how much I loved, loved, LOVED Elliot tonight. That song was terrific!
Originally Posted By Lisann22 Me too Jazzy - he was SO awesome!!!! I felt like I was sitting in a jazz club listening to a really really good singer. He nailed it. I know people have made fun of his looks, but in his own way - he's got it.
Originally Posted By JazzCat Hey, I'm certainly NOT 11 and I really liked Will! I think what he meant is that Kenny Rogers sings country music and a great majority of Texans like country music as well. That's how I interpreted it anyway.
