Originally Posted By amazedncal2 Cripes, DH pointed out that I was getting Neil Young and Neil Diamond mixed up Sorry. I can probably stand Neil Diamond songs for one night. He looks absolutely creepy in his glittering vest on those darned commercials though. I hope he doesn't wear the vest No "Sweet Caroline" though please.
Originally Posted By sun-n-fun I didn't wasnt Carly to make it to the end but Jason and Brooke should have gone first. As a woman I think Brooke is annoying. I don't even find her nice, just sickingfly sweet to the point of being phoney and somewhat arragant. I hate the way she talks back although did like that she admitted it!
Originally Posted By DAR Okay I thought the first half was a weak showing by everyone. Mr. Diamond deserves better than that. The second half I liked David Cook and Brooke the best.
Originally Posted By SFH Paula reading her lines ahead of time was the best part of last night's show.
Originally Posted By TXDISNEYNERD Yes Paula was um.. interesting last night. I think the bottom two has got to be Brooke and Jason. Either one can go home IMHO. David Cook is the best. Does Jason remind anyone else of Lord of the Rings? For some reason, I can't look at him without thinking he is a long lost relative of the elves and he is going to pull out his bow and arrow at any moment now.
Originally Posted By Rsey103 >>Paula reading her lines ahead of time was the best part of last night's show.<< Their song critiques are written by them or for them before the show??? And why didn't the panel comment on the first songs last night? Is Jason's hair real?
Originally Posted By imadisneygal ^^^ 1. No, they're usually off the cuff. 2. Time constraints because each contestant sang two songs last night. They commented all at once between the first and second songs. 3. Yes, it is.
Originally Posted By Inspector 57 Ironically, the loser's song sounded 300% better when performed tonight than last night's version, IMHO.
Originally Posted By sun-n-fun I was sooooo glad to see Brooke leave. Jason must have a huge fan base. Friends from home and a slew of girls (apparently even though I do not see the appeal). I can't figure out how he was not in the bottom 2 or 3.
Originally Posted By imadisneygal Seriously. What the heck?! Jason is fine, I guess...but he does not have the talent to be this far along in the competition over some of the others who have already left. As others have said, he must have a huge fan base. And yuck...dreadlocks gross me out. I don't think Brooke, or Michael Johns for that matter, would have won but in my opinion they deserved to be on the show longer than Jason. I he outlasts either of the Davids I'll have lost faith in the show. At least until next season when I'll again be watching with baited breath!
Originally Posted By SFH It's down to fan bases at this point, and has been at least the week Carly was voted out when Brooke or Jason should have gone. Now that there is only one female left, I predict Jason will go next because S. will get many of B.'s voters. Of course, I could be completely wrong. SFH
Originally Posted By Rsey103 I think Sayesha will be the next to go, followed by Jason--leaving the 2 Davids to fight it out in the end. (With Cook winning..)
Originally Posted By sun-n-fun I hope Syesha continues to the top 3. As much as I like her, I don't think she is as good as the Davids. I like to think people vote for talent, but I know they always don't. As long as she holds her own, I'll vote for her next week.
Originally Posted By Dabob2 This year has been disappointing to me. It's been pretty clear for a while it was going to be David vs. David in the final 2; whether Jason (who should have left long ago) or Syesha leaves next week is almost immaterial.
Originally Posted By topdisneymom I can't beleive it! Vote for the worst is still going strong. <a href="http://www.votefortheworst.com/node?page=1" target="_blank">http://www.votefortheworst.com...e?page=1</a>
Originally Posted By RoadTrip ^^^ Yes, I almost wish they would cut it to the final two next week and get it over with. Everyone on earth knows it's going to be Good David vs. Squinting David in the final. Although if squint DID win, it would be kind of unique. AI wins AI.
Originally Posted By mele If David A wins, it will continue my very long tradition of never owning any AI music!
Originally Posted By sun-n-fun The only AI music I own is Daughtry. No one else has even remotely appealed to me
