Originally Posted By amazedncal2 LOL! ecdc We usually listen to a bit of Randy's opinion but actually you can just watch him and know what he is saying, skip Kara, skip Paula and listen to Simon.
Originally Posted By amazedncal2 OH MY GOSH!!!! um...........Tatania seemed to flop her way back in......making 602 dalmatians
Originally Posted By Labuda I'm not at all heartbroken that Scott is gone. Nice guy, good singer, but not GREAT. As for Glamberts, I'm one of 'em! I bought his studio recording of Mad World off itunes. That's now THREE copies of that song on my ipod.
Originally Posted By disneylandfan8 I am such a Glambert nerd. I have purchased all the performance videos and studio songs of Adam (except I Can't Get No Satisfaction, but will probably fix that soon!)
Originally Posted By danyoung Well, I do have a history of saving video from what I think are top notch performances, and the only 2 I've saved this year are both from Adam - Mad World and Tracks Of My Tears.
Originally Posted By Rsey103 I so don't enjoy Lil Rounds and I agreed with Simon when he said she's not the artist they thought she was 7 or 8 weeks ago... She didn't do herself any favors by talking back to the judges (which Ryan urged her to do even tho they were out of time.) She made it to the top 7 now it's time for her to go...
Originally Posted By Inspector 57 With all due respect to my friend Labuda... Tarantino... blech! Yes, he knows film, and film and music, and performance. But... blech! I don't like the new format change they've made for this week. Mr. Bill just made a hilarious comment about Adam's performance. But I'll save that 'til the Right Coast people have had a chance to see the show.
Originally Posted By Rsey103 Did you notice that Paula and Simon got to critique the top tier contestants?
Originally Posted By Inspector 57 I'm holding off on commenting on that until the California people get to see the show.
Originally Posted By danyoung In my opinion, the California people can wait to look at this thread till they've seen the show. It's what I do when I have to wait to watch the next day. I think Lil is gone.
Originally Posted By Inspector 57 When California people see that there's a new post on this thread, they can't tell if it relates to prior discussion or to the newest episode until they click on it. I'd rather err on the side of being respectful.
Originally Posted By disneylandfan8 OK, California has seen the show... What was Mr. Bill's comment? I just watched all the performances and I must say, I wasn't really wowed by anyone in particular. Adam's was the best of all of them, but he's done better. Not sure if I'm going to download this performance. I'll have to watch it a few more times. And, yes, I think the bottom two will be Lil and Anoop. Sorry.
Originally Posted By trekkeruss Based on tonight's performances, I don't think Anoop should be in the bottom two, but he'll probably be there anyway. Personally, I would put Matt and Lil in the B2, with Lil sent packing.
Originally Posted By Inspector 57 I was wow'd by Adam's performance. During the song, I commented that I thought he had "made it his own," that he was totally rocking, and that he reminded me of Axl Rose. Mr. Bill responded, "Eh, not so much Axl. He's more Liza Minnelli."
Originally Posted By Inspector 57 I'm not sure which of the guys I'd put into the bottom three, but I'd put both of the girls there, for sure.
Originally Posted By Lisann22 Nobody wow'd be this week. I thought it was all pretty boring. I think the bottom Three will be Lil, Matt and either Chris or Allyson. Won't bother me if Lil, Chris or Matt go. It'll probably be Lil. What a waste. She just never developed. It didn't bother me that she spoke up last night. I don't think she was disrespectful, she was trying to justify why she did what she did. I'm sure she's frustrated, she's taken a pounding for several weeks. She wasn't a smartass or anything. Scott did pretty much the same thing last week.
Originally Posted By danyoung >When California people see that there's a new post on this thread, they can't tell if it relates to prior discussion or to the newest episode until they click on it.< Hmmm, yes, that's always a possibility. How do I handle it? Let's see, it's a hypothetical Wednesday morning, I haven't seen last night's hypothetical show, and I get a message that there's an addition to the American Idol thread. Hmmm, is it possible that people are commenting on last night's show? Well, maybe, so just in case, I better not frikkin' read the thread till I've seen the show!!! Sorry for the sarcasm, but I don't feel the need to protect others from their stupidity.
Originally Posted By amazedncal2 DH said "Axl Rose" too Bottom 3 for me are Lil, Matt and Chris. I didn't recognize Chris' song, so maybe it was OK, I dunno. One of the favorite parts of the show for me is after Adam or Danny sings. They smile like they are happy it's over and they are ready for the judging. Just nice smiles, nothing corny, maybe they are looking at their families
Originally Posted By TXDISNEYNERD Lil, Matt, and Anoop are my bottom three this week with Lil going home. Adam is just so talented. It wasn't his best performance, but was still amazing. I hate only two judges speaking after a performance. What is the purpose then of having 4 judges? I think they will go back down to 3 after this season.
